The idea that simple actions such as talking, laughing, crying, and other natural expressions can influence our physical health, dates back to the 19th century, and Harry Campbell’s observations published in the The Lancet in 1897 laid the groundwork for understanding how these actions affect circulation.
Campbells original paper is fairly easy to read and still relevant physiologically, if unavoidably culturally dated (1). Modern research findings support his central premise; that actions such as talking, laughing, and crying profoundly benefit the body's lymphatic and venous systems, and further broadens our understanding of the role of these natural expressions in health and well-being.
This post explores how laughing influences lymph flow and venous return, integrating historical perspectives and contemporary research to offer actionable insights.
Campbell's Observations from 1897 London
Harry Campbell MD FRCP was Physician to the sick and injured at the North-West London Hospital who were mostly poor working-class women; and Surgeon to the wealthy residents of Marylebone at his Wimpole St Rooms.
Over 125 years ago, Campbell identified the physiological benefits of talking, shouting, singing , laughing, crying, sighing and yawning (1).
His paper in the Lancet describes how these activities act on respiratory movements, influence blood and lymph circulation, and support abdominal and pelvic organ function.
According to Campbell, actions like shouting and singing release neuro-muscular energy, alleviate psychological tension, and promote holistic well-being.
His insights remain relevant today, providing a framework for understanding the therapeutic potential of these everyday acts.
Insights from 20th Century research have validated many of Campbell's observations on the physiological and psychological benefits of talking and laughing in chronic diseases, including lymphoedema (2).
Key Physiological Effects Noted by Campbell:
Enhanced Circulation: Respiratory modifications during talking, laughing, and crying aid venous return and lymphatic drainage.
Emotional Regulation: Acts like laughing or crying reduce nerve tension and contribute to psychological balance.
Systemic Benefits: These expressions involve deep respiratory movements, stimulating abdominal and pelvic viscera and improving overall circulation.
Modern Science: Validating Campbell’s Observations
Recent research corroborates Campbell’s findings, highlighting the interconnectedness of respiratory mechanics, circulation, and emotional health.
1. Laughing and the Lymphatic System
Laughter involves rhythmic respiratory movements that enhance intrathoracic pressure changes, facilitating lymphatic and venous return. Studies by Hasan and Hasan (2009) demonstrated laughter's impact on reducing stress and enhancing circulation (3). Additionally, laughter therapy has been shown to alleviate pain and improve emotional well-being in cancer patients (4).
Practical Applications:
Laughter Therapy in Healthcare: Incorporating laughter into treatment plans for chronic diseases, such as lymphoedema and arthritis, may improve patients’ emotional and physical health.
Laughing Yoga Social Laughter in Rehabilitation: Group therapy and social interactions encouraging laughter can support lymphatic drainage and enhance patient outcomes.
2. Crying and Emotional Release
Crying, particularly sobbing, involves deep, rhythmic respirations that compress abdominal and thoracic cavities, stimulating venous return.
Beyond its mechanical effects, crying facilitates the release of endorphins, natural painkillers that improve mood and reduce stress.
Campbell’s argument that crying should not be overly suppressed finds support in modern psychology, with studies emphasising its role in emotional catharsis.
Modern techniques such as guided emotional release therapy can help individuals navigate grief, trauma, and anxiety.
Practical Applications:
Therapeutic Crying: Encouraging clients to express emotions that arise spontaneously during treatment can provide relief from psychological stress, benefiting mental health and circulation. However Practitioners who are not trained in emotional release should be cautious not to deliberately elicit emotional responses without the training to support them.
3. Talking as a Cardiovascular Exercise
Talking engages respiratory and cardiovascular systems, with benefits comparable to light exercise. Campbell noted that talking is particularly beneficial in conditions like passive pulmonary congestion (congestive heart failure).
Modern studies expand this view, linking talking and social interactions to improved mental health and longevity.
Practical Applications:
Personal Engagement in Chronic Illness: Encouraging people to converse regularly can improve respiratory function and cardiovascular health.
Public Speaking and Rehabilitation: Activities involving speech, such as singing or group discussions, can serve as therapeutic exercises for individuals recovering from illness or surgery.
The Role of Emotion in Physical Health
The interconnectedness of the lymphatic, circulatory, and emotional systems is well-documented. The limbic system, a brain region involved in emotion regulation, influences the autonomic nervous system and, consequently, lymphatic function. Techniques such as laughing yoga demonstrate how harnessing emotional and physical expressions can optimise health.
Neurobiological Mechanisms:
Endorphin Release: Both laughter and crying stimulate the production of endorphins, reducing pain and enhancing mood (Dunbar et al., 2002)(6).
Vagal Stimulation: Activities like sighing or laughing activate the parasympathetic nervous system via the vagus nerve, promoting relaxation and improved blood flow (Vanhaudenhuyse et al., 2009) (7).
Stress Reduction: Emotional expressions decrease cortisol levels, mitigating chronic inflammation and its effects on the lymphatic system.
Practical Recommendations for Allied Health Professionals:
Encourage activities that combine emotional expression with physical movement, such as group singing or laughter yoga.
Recognise the emotional states of your clients and use humour to foster emotional balance.
Addressing Chronic Conditions: A Multi-Pronged Approach
Research underscores the importance of movement, emotion, and respiratory function in managing chronic conditions such as lymphoedema, arthritis, and cancer-related stress.
1. Lymphoedema Management:
Ryan (2019) highlighted the value of encouraging movement and maintaining an upbeat emotional state to enhance lymphatic flow. Laughter yoga and breathing exercises should be incorporated into care plans to stimulate circulation and lymphatic drainage (2).
2. Arthritis and Pain Management:
Skevington and White (1998) found that humour and laughter were among the most effective coping mechanisms for patients with chronic arthritis. Group-based humour interventions may prevent depression and improve coping mechanisms (5).
3. Cancer Care:
Laughter therapy has proven benefits in reducing anxiety, stress, and depression in cancer patients, as noted by Shi et al. (2024). Psychosocial interventions incorporating humour and emotional expression should be integrated into oncology care (4).
Practical Tips for Allied Health Professionals
Incorporate Laughter into Treatment: Encourage clients to watch comedic content, participate in laughter yoga, or engage in social interactions that elicit laughter.
Normalise Crying: Educate clients on the physiological benefits of crying and create a supportive environment for emotional expression.
Leverage Talking and Singing: Promote group discussions, therapy sessions, and singing classes as tools to enhance respiratory function and emotional well-being.
Advocate for Movement: Combine emotional exercises with physical activity to maximize benefits for lymphatic and venous systems.
Use Biofeedback: Introduce techniques to train patients in deep breathing and mindful emotional regulation, tapping into the parasympathetic system for relaxation and circulation improvements.
Conclusion
The benefits of talking, laughing, and crying extend far beyond mere emotional expression. These natural acts enhance lymph flow, support venous return, and improve overall health. Building on Campbell's pioneering insights, modern research underscores the therapeutic potential of these expressions. By integrating these principles into practice, allied health professionals can support holistic healing, empowering patients to harness the profound benefits of their own emotions and movements.
References
Campbell, H. (1897). The therapeutical aspects of talking, shouting, sighing, laughing, crying, sighing, and yawning. The Lancet. https://baillement.com/lettres/campbell1897.pdf
Ryan T. The nature of care in the management of lymphoedema; not without laughter! Journal of Lymphoedema. 2019; 14(1).
Hasan H, Hasan TF. Laugh yourself into a healthier person: A cross-cultural analysis. Int J Med Sci. 2009; 6(4):200-211.
Shi H, Wu Y, Wang L, Zhou X, Li F. Effects of laughter therapy on improving negative emotions associated with cancer. Oncology. 2024; 102(4):343–353.
Skevington SM, White A. Is laughter the best medicine? Psychology & Health. 1998; 13(1):157–169.
Dunbar RIM, Baron R, Frangou A, et al. Social laughter is correlated with an elevated pain threshold. Proc Biol Sci. 2012; 279(1731):1161–1167.
Vanhaudenhuyse A, et al. Yoga and autonomic balance. Pain Med. 2009.
Wishing everyone a happy Holiday Season 💐 🎁🎄🥳🎈